Recently by Michael Tennant: Boehner: No One Reads GOP Platform
In what his attorney called a huge victory for food freedom, a Minnesota farmer was acquitted by a jury of the crime of distributing unpasteurized milk to members of a food cooperative.
On September 20, after a three-day trial and more than four hours of deliberation, reported the Minneapolis Star Tribune, a Hennepin County jury found Alvin Schlangen not guilty of three misdemeanor counts of selling unpasteurized milk, operating without a food license and handling adulterated or misbranded food. Each count carried a maximum sentence of three months imprisonment.
Schlangen, an organic egg farmer from Freeport, Minn., doesnt produce milk himself but operates Freedom Farms Co-op, a private club with roughly 130 members who buy various farm products, including raw milk, the paper explained. Schlangen picks up the milk products from an Amish farm and delivers them to members.
The charges are based on commerce and theres no commerce here, the 54-year-old Schlangen told the Star Tribune. Its a completely different food system than what we are accustomed to.
Two co-op members testified to the private nature of their arrangements with Schlangen. One, Kathryn Niflis Johnson, told the court, As a member we lease/own the animals. We place an order and food products are delivered by Alvin. We pay the proportional amount for labor and overhead it takes to produce the food. Asked by prosecutor Michelle Doffing Baynes if she had bought other products from Schlangen, Johnson replied, I dont know if bought is the right word, but I usually get eggs and milk and maybe other things in the past… You have to understand that this is a whole new model and that we dont necessarily have the right words to describe what we are doing.
The reason Minnesotans must make such complicated arrangements to obtain certain fresh farm products is that state law restricts the sale of these products raw-milk products in particular to the farms where they are produced. Schlangen, noted the Star Tribune, called the law absurd, since it implies the same batch of raw milk is safe at the farm, but not if sold in the Twin Cities. James Roettger, a senior inspector for the Minnesota Department of Agriculture (MDA), actually testified that raw milk should be consumed on the same day it is produced, suggesting that raw milk kept any longer could become dangerous, according to raw-milk advocate David Gumpert.
Minnesota is the most oppressive state in terms of freedom of food choice, Farm-to-Consumer Legal Defense Fund president Peter Kennedy told the Star Tribune. (Kennedys organization paid for Schlangens defense.) Schlangen found that out firsthand, telling Gumpert that on March 9, 2011:
The MDA stopped and illegally seized, searched and confiscated the property carried in the private delivery truck belonging to the Schlangen family farm. This action occurred at the foot of a sports stadium at St[.] Paul Macalester College, where a group of students were able to connect with the Schlangen farm for their choice of local sustainable eggs. I was not allowed to deliver the product of my farm to the college group that day. In fact, those very eggs were confiscated, along with fresh farm dairy food that belonged to the members of newly formed Freedom Farms Coop.
The same day, the (food clubs leased warehouse space) was raided, food was seized as well as packaging material including empty milk crates, even several gallons of used veggie oil that was potential fuel for the delivery rig. With a wholesale value of more than $5,000, this was in fact grand larceny, aggravated and pre-meditated, by MDA officers.