As the Obama administration is poised to enact a sweeping infringement of the right of Americans to keep and bear arms in the states bordering Mexico, the only thing which may stand in the way is not the Republican-dominated House of Representatives, but the Federal Paperwork Reduction Act.
The scale of the revision in U.S. law which the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives (still known as ATF) is contemplating is breathtaking; as noted in a recent Reuters article: The measure would require around 8,500 gun dealers in Arizona, California, New Mexico and Texas to report sales of two or more high-powered semi-automatic rifles with detachable magazines to the same person within a five-day period. The supposed rationale for this action is to reduce the flow of arms to Mexico, which is rapidly devolving into a civil war between the central government and drug cartels. The sketchy connection between interfering with the second amendment rights of American citizens and the failed state south of our border is a GAO study which attempts to link American firearms to the conflict, and the Reuters article dutifully repeats the Obama administration line on this point:
The move to boost ATF’s ability to target gun traffickers comes as Mexican authorities are struggling to contain raging drug violence south of the border, where shootouts, beheadings and torture killings are a daily occurrence.
About 90 percent of the crime guns seized and traced in Mexico last year were initially sold in the United States, according to ATF. Investigators say around three-quarters of traces lead back to sales in the four states flanking the U.S. border.
This "iron river" of firearms flowing south to the drug cartels includes high powered Kalashnikov and AR-15 rifles toted by cartel hitmen across Mexico, and decorative .38 caliber pistols popular with drug kingpins.
The highly misleading GAO statistic cited by the ATF has been refuted. Consider the following analysis from the July 2009 issue of Second Amendment Foundations Gottlieb-Tartaro Report:
The GAO obediently came up with some sensational numbers: about 87 percent of firearms seized by Mexican authorities and traced in the last 5 years originated in the United States. If true, it would be a huge failure of our border patrol. [Emphasis in original.]
Nullification: How to ... Best Price: $2.00 Buy New $8.34 (as of 05:25 UTC - Details)
Not only that, the report emphasized, Many of these firearms come from gun shops and gun shows in Southwest border states. Its as if these law-abiding Americans were deliberately supplying Mexican gun smugglers. [Emphasis in original.]
The GAO report is just to get more gun control laws. In fact, that 87 percent number for U.S. guns seized and traced in Mexico is a flat lie.
The real number is closer to 22 percent, but you cant tell until 21 pages into the GAO report. The discrepancy is in what the GAO counted: only guns traced, not guns seized. A lot of guns (30,000) were seized, but few traced (7,200).
Page 21 of the report says, In 2008, of the almost 30,000 firearms that the Mexican Attorney Generals office said were seized, only around 7,200, or approximately a quarter, were submitted to ATF for tracing.
It was 87 percent of those 7,200 that were traced to the U.S., but thats only about 25 percent of the 30,000 seized. Thats a prime example of How to Lie With Statistics, as author Darrell Huff titled his 1993 book.
Far from an iron river," the flow of arms from the United States is more like an arroyo, which is a channel of bare earth until a storm comes along.
January 10, 2011