Let me tell you a few things about blasphemy. Been there, done it. Got expelled from high school for it.
That was a few decades ago, and for those seeking titillation, Ill give you the details at the end of this screed. First I have to tell you about a massive propaganda coup. Youve been had by some of the most bigoted people in the world and Im not talking about Muslim fundamentalists.
The big news about blasphemy today is in the Muslim world. A Danish newspaper, Jyllands-Posten, in September published 12 cartoons mocking the prophet Muhammad. It took four months for that fuse to reach the powder keg of religious sensibilities the flame was relentlessly pushed along by the right-wing, neo-conservative press until it exploded. The dumbed-down media depiction was free speech versus intolerant Muslim fanatics. Thats not entirely wrong, just very incomplete. Ultimately, crowds erupted in protests in Muslim cities. The picture of the burning Danish consulate in Beirut is the icon of the day.
I have to admit a severe conflict of principles here. On the one hand, I want to shout: I am Danish! Cartoons dont kill, bombs do! I dont countenance any prior restraint on freedom of expression, and when I first read of the Muslim outrage over cartoons such as one depicting Mohammeds turban as a bomb I sighed a deep sigh of regret. Theres no dialogue in burning embassies.
Should free speech have constraints? Official censorship is anathema to a free society. Self-censorship and spinning for a regime la Fox News is just as corrosive. On the other hand, I think the media should be very judicious about gratuitous offense. Im repulsed at such things as artist Andres Serranos Piss Christ. And, I feel no need to antagonize Muslims, Hindus, Wiccans or any other religious groups by intentionally creating an affront to their faith. I even have respect for the misbegotten gospel of the (un)Christian Coalition.
That the Muslim world reacted with violence to the cartoons is abhorrent. That Christians have done the same thing lighting up town centers and hilltops across Europe with flaming heretics and blasphemers is just as abhorrent. Indeed, the theocratic movement in America, which would enshrine one narrow view of Christs teachings as the law of the land, is simply a variation on the Muslim fundamentalists bellowing hatred at Scandinavian businesses and government offices.
There are other caveats that need to be stated: The Muslim world has been under assault from western, Christian crusaders for a thousand years. Weve colonized and despoiled their lands. Many in America regard their oil as rightfully ours an underlying if not complete explanation for George Bushs war of conquest. Weve carved up the Middle East, overthrown democracies (pre-Shah Iran, for example), and fostered despots to suit the Wests imperial whims. And we wonder why THEY dont like us, and why THEY take insults from us so seriously.
So, lets look at the guy who started this whole cartoon escapade. Hes Flemming Rose, the cultural editor of the Danish newspaper. In all of the Lexis-Nexis database of stories from the American media on the Mohammed cartoons, there is absolutely no mention of the fact that Rose is a close confederate of arch-Islamophobe Daniel Pipes. Indeed, there is almost no context at all about Roses newspaper. On a brief mention in the Washington Post gave a hint at a fact desperately needed to understand the situation. The Post described the affair as a calculated insult by a right-wing newspaper in a country where bigotry toward the minority Muslim population is a major, if frequently unacknowledged, problem.
How bad is Pipes? He wants the utter military obliteration of the Palestinians; indeed, from the Muslim world, his racism is about as blatant as that of the Holocaust denying Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad. Pipes frequent outbursts of racism designed to toss gasoline on the neo-cons lust for a wholesale conflict of cultures earned him a Bush nomination to the U.S. Institute of Peace, a congressionally funded think tank. Rose came to America to commune with Pipes in 2004, and it was after that meeting the cartoon gambit materialized.
Its also worth noting that Danish Prime Minister Anders Fogh Rasmussen wrapped himself in protestations about freedom of speech, and thats commendable. But he is one of Bushs few fans in Europe, steeped in the we-versus-them rhetoric, and having sent troops to the Iraqi Crusade.
Is Rose an equal opportunity offender? No way. As the British press reported last week, his newspaper refused in 2003 to run cartoons that ridiculed Jesus. And, of course, free expression in Europe is very relative. Many of the democracies have laws banning certain speech.
Rose gave a rather misanthropic rejoinder to AP when asked about whether he would have published the cartoons in light of the subsequent protests. Rose said: "I do not regret having commissioned those cartoons and I think asking me that question is like asking a rape victim if she regrets wearing a short skirt Friday night at the discotheque."
That, of course, makes the assumption that women are responsible for being raped. Its just as fallacious as assuming the Muslim world should passively accept an intentional provocation, one that gratuitously attacked one of the religions strictest prohibitions.
Was the reaction overwrought? Absolutely. Was it predictable? Absolutely. Was it an intentional scheme to provoke Arab anger, and thereby engender Western disgust with the Muslim world? The involvement of Pipes and Rose argues that that is exactly what happened.
Now, my confession of blasphemy. In 1963, as an art student in Miami, I was assigned to a safety poster, Cross at the corner. I (humorously) depicted a crucified Christ at a Miami street corner looking down very sadly at people doing all sorts of horrible things to each other. My principal wasnt amused, called me sacrilegious and a blasphemer, and tossed me from school. I got back in the First Amendment was still alive and well. And, fortunately, none of my supporters (there were quite a few) burned any consulates.
February 16, 2006