As Santayana
observed, those who forget history are doomed to relive it.
However overused, his maxim is as true today as when he made
it.
On 15 February,
1989, the 40th Soviet Army pulled out of Afghanistan,
marking the end of Moscow’s bloody and disastrous occupation.
Its able commander, Gen. Boris Gromov, was the last Soviet solider
to leave Afghanistan, leading his men over a bridge spanning
the Amu Darya River (Oxus, in Greek) – which Alexander the Great
had crossed on his ill-fated invasion of Afghanistan (327–325
BC).
In a decade
of savage fighting, the Red Army and its Afghan Communist allies
killed at least 1.5 million Afghans and drove 2.5 million into
exile in Pakistan and Iran.
The new
Soviet chairman, Mikhail Gorbachev, determined the Afghan war,
that was begun by his dimwitted predecessor, Leonid Brezhnev,
and a cabal of party and KGB hardliners, could not be won.
Fortunately
for the world, Gorbachev, proved a leader of profound humanity,
decency, and intellect. Gorbachev courageously accepted defeat
and brought his soldiers home. Soon after, the Soviet Union,
a bankrupt empire held together by fear and repression, began
to crumble. To his eternal credit, Gorbachev refused to employ
force to hold the Soviet Empire together.
Many Russians
detest Gorbachev to this day, blaming him for the end of the
Soviet Union. But using the Red Army to crush rebellion in the
Baltic republics and East Germany could easily have ignited
World War III. The world owes Gorbachev an enormous debt for
averting this horror. He put humanism ahead of nationalism and
imperialism.
The new
president of the bankrupt American imperium should heed Gorbachev’s
wisdom. Barack Obama’s inauguration offered a perfect opportunity
to pause the US-led Afghan War, and open talks with Afghan groups
resisting foreign occupation (both the Soviets and US branded
them "terrorists"). Instead, Obama vowed to intensify
the eight-year war which has so far cost the US $ 62 billion.
President
Obama declared he will send 17,000 more US troops to Afghanistan
on top of the 6,000 troops dispatched by George Bush. Another
13,000 will follow in the spring, raising the total US garrison
to at least 66,000. These reinforcements are supposed to come
from US occupation forces in Iraq.
But Pentagon
hardliners and their Republican allies are trying to delay or
thwart the troop drawdown from Iraq. Equally, I suspect that
Iraq is in a temporary lull. Pulling out US forces may prove
far harder than Obama expects.
Afghanistan
is no longer George Bush’s War. It’s now President Obama’s War.
Obama just defined his goals in Afghanistan as: "preventing
it from being used as a launching pad for attacks on North America"
and "defeating al-Qaida." He also allowed that some
sort of negotiations to split Taliban might be attempted.
Both stated
goals are patently false. 9/11 was organized in Germany and
Spain, allegedly by Saudis and Pakistanis. Attacks on New York,
Washington, London, Madrid and Mumbai were plotted in apartments
and houses, not the mountains of Afghanistan. Most of the so-called
"terrorist training camps in Afghanistan in 2001"
were actually camps run by Pakistan intelligence where mujahidin
were being prepared to fight in Indian-held Kashmir.
Al-Qaida
never had more than 300 men and is today reduced to a handful
of fugitives hiding in Pakistan’s tribal territories and Baluchistan.
The movement’s primary function, as my new book explains, was
as a guest house and data base for foreign mujahidin fighting
the Soviets and Afghan Communists. It was not and is not a "worldwide
terrorist organization." Catching al-Qaida’s survivors
requires police work, not thousands of heavy troops.
By expanding
the Afghan war, Obama fuels the growing threat of a major explosion
in Pakistan. Today, US warplanes and CIA killer drones operate
from three secret Pakistani air bases with covert Pakistani
government cooperation. Washington has rented 120,000 Pakistani
troops for $100 million monthly (plus equally large, secret
CIA payments to senior Pakistani government officials and officers)
to support the US occupation of Afghanistan.
In an unprecedented
act, Pakistan’s government is being paid by Washington to attack
its own people, and to allow US forces to do the same. Watching
Pakistan’s new government dance to Washington’s tune is an embarrassing
spectacle for friends of Pakistan, and a subject of sneering
contempt for its foes.
Pakistan
is bankrupt. The previous US-backed Musharraf regime made off
with whatever money there was. Yet at some point, Pakistan’s
rent-an-army of modern-day sepoys may rebel and turn against
the government that orders it to kill fellow Muslims while letting
India expand its influence in Afghanistan and crush independence-fighters
in Kashmir.
Meanwhile,
high expectations held by many Americans for Obama are fading.
To the anguish of America’s antiwar movement, his administration
seems set on continuing many of the illegal, repressive policies
of the disgraced Bush White House that it had vowed to end:
torture, kidnapping, wiretapping, assassinations, Constitutional
infringements, denial of due process.
Guantanamo
may be closed, but the equally cruel US gulag at Bagram, Afghanistan
remains open. None of the Bush administration officials who
sanctioned torture and other crimes will face justice.
What happened
to the Obama who was supposed to bring change? Leftover hardliners
from the Bush days appear to be driving Obama’s foreign policy
in Afghanistan. The mighty Israel lobby retains its hammer-lock
on US Mideast policy. During the Gaza bombings by Israel, Obama
ducked out of sight and remained mute.
The Pentagon
warns that a defeat of NATO in Afghanistan will destroy the
alliance – the foundation of US hegemony over Europe. After
Iraq, another defeat cannot be tolerated.
Soviet
veterans of Afghanistan warn the US and its allies face defeat
there. The Obama White House cannot even articulate a coherent
political strategy for Afghanistan. Its latest big idea is to
kick out the hapless Hamid Karzai and install a new "asset,"
one of the CIA-groomed "good" Afghans who the Taliban
leader, Mullah Omar, colorfully brands "dog-washers."
Washington
hopes US troop reinforcements will finally bludgeon the Afghan
national resistance into accepting American domination. Then
the long-planned pipeline from the Caspian Basin across Afghanistan
to Pakistan can finally be built.
Talk about
fiddling while Rome burns. It turns out the real national security
threat to America was not Osama bin Laden or Mullah Omar, but
the unsupervised, crooked financiers and reckless gamblers on
Wall Street who wrecked America’s economy and endangered global
financial stability.
They were
not in Afghanistan, but downtown New York City.