The Face in the Mirror
by
Tom
Engelhardt
by Tom Engelhardt
Recently by Tom Engelhardt: Are
Afghan Lives Worth Anything?
Last year,
at my birthday, I wrote "When
I'm 64...," a post about war and (lack of) peace in my time.
Another year has rolled around, as it tends to do, so think of what
follows as further scribbled notes, stuffed in an e-bottle, and
set afloat, all part of a future memoir I'll never write. If you
finish and have the urge to know more about a Cold War childhood
(and many other matters), check out the updated edition of my book,
The
End of Victory Culture. If you enjoy my description of my
early reading experiences, then consider picking up a copy of my
2003 novel, The
Last Days of Publishing, which, sadly, turned out to be prescient
when it came to the problematic present of my
lifelong business and avocation. ~ Tom
Borrowed Time:
The
World at 65
"Being an
historian, I am jotting down these notes out of habit; but what
I saw and experienced two days ago I am sure no one else as civilized
as I am will ever see. I am writing for those who shall come a long
time from now."
So began "The
Prophecy," a mock futuristic fantasy set after some great Cold War
cataclysm, which several members of my high school graduating class
collaborated on back in 1962. It was, of course, for our yearbook
and made fun of the class, A to Z. It was also a classic document
of the moment, written by representatives of the first generation
of "teenagers" who, crouching under their school desks as the sirens
of an atomic-attack drill howled outside, imagined that no one in
their world might make it.
"First of
all, let me introduce myself," "I" continued. "I am Thomas M. Engelhardt,
world renowned historian of the late twentieth century, should that
mean anything to whoever reads this account. After the great invasion,
I was maintaining a peaceful, contented existence in the private
shelter I had built, and was completing the ninth and final volume
of my masterpiece, The Influence of the Civil War on Mexican
Art of the Twentieth Century..."
Okay, so they
had me pegged. Not only, in those years, did I read whatever post-nuclear
pulp fiction I could get my hands on you know, the kind with
landscapes filled with atomic mutants and survivalist communities
but I was a Civil War nut. Past disasters and future catastrophes,
and somehow it all made sense.
I was, in
fact, a nut for the American past generally, in part, I suspect,
because the familial past wasn't available. My parents, typically
enough for second and third generation Americans, were in flight
from their own pasts, from all that not-so-distant squalor and unhappiness,
or just plain foreign-ness, much the way, once upon a time, so many
other Americans had fled small towns for the Big City.
My father rarely
spoke of his own life his parents, his childhood, his years
growing up, the Great Depression, and especially his experiences
in World War II (and in this he was typical of a generation that
did not come home from the grimmest of wars with the idea that they
were "the greatest"). My mother acted as if her past were the proverbial
blank slate. She told but three stories from her childhood: one
in which she broke her nose in a softball game, another in which
she jumped out of a second-story window to test whether a sheet
would work as a parachute, and a third in which an evil but rich
uncle humiliated her loveable but ne'er-do-well inventor of a father.
Perhaps that
very past-less-ness left me with a yen for roots, which I then found
in the sole place available: American history. Toss in the time
an only child had in a room still surprisingly bare of entertainment,
and it was hardly surprising that, as early as third grade, I started
devouring the biographies hagiographies actually of
assorted American heroes. They were little books focusing on Kit
Carson or Clara Barton with memorably orange covers.
And not so
long after, I graduated to the Landmark Books series, back in the
days when history was still a series of accepted and acceptable
"landmarks": Ben
Franklin of Old Philadelphia, The
Pony Express, Gettysburg,
The
Panama Canal, Custer's
Last Stand. By high school, I was ingesting every book the
popular Civil War historian Bruce Catton ever wrote. I was, by then,
a proud subscriber to the classy American history magazine, American
Heritage, thought of the American past as mine, memorized famous
speeches by generals and presidents in my spare time, and so was
an all-too-inviting target for a little teenage fun.
Quoits,
Anyone?
Tomorrow,
I turn 65, an age I simply never imagined for myself back in those
youthful years. And the past, I must admit, now lurks somewhat closer
to home, as of course does the future, my future. Sometimes these
days, when I catch a glimpse of myself in the mirror the
bald head, the mustache that's gone silvery white, the little bumps
and discolorations of every sort, in short, that aging face
I see my long-dead father staring back. Each time, it's a visceral
shock. Like an ambush. Like a sucker punch in the gut. I feel horror
not him, not in my face! and love, but not acceptance.
Not yet anyway.
I can't begin
to tell you how eerie it feels when the past resides not in some
book, but like a still-developing snapshot, a blurry subway portrait
of the dead, in your own face. It led me recently to pull
down from the topmost reaches of my closet some of my old family
photos, many of them now beyond meaning, the equivalents of inscriptions
in the hieroglyphs of an unknown language. For this part of my private
past, there are no witnesses left. Not a one. No one who can fill
me in on the dramatis personae.
The oldest
of the albums I have, my mother's, I discovered only after both
my parents were dead: two-holed and horizontal, a black cover with
the words "Snap Shots" on it, each black page now loose of any binding,
edges crumbling as if nibbled by mice.
Only several
pages in do I first recognize, in an elfin child's face, the woman
who would become my mother and would die in 1977, so long ago that
sometimes I hardly believe she existed.
There she
is, though, perhaps six or seven, standing in a garden in a battered
brimmed hat, wearing long rubber gloves, a shirt and pants, and
looking for all the world like a street urchin from some Charlie
Chaplin silent film. The album is, of course, her story the
one she never told me of her Chicago world just after the
turn of the last century. There are young boys with bikes and girls
with flowers, girls doing headstands and boys strutting their stuff,
friends lined up arm-in-arm, college students in their toques, and
adults who, in their formality, look to be from yet another century.
All unknown to me, all lost to whatever lies beneath history, beyond
memory.
Still, one
thing is unmistakable: this is a record book of dreams and memories.
There are her recital cards and yearly marks (E for "accuracy,"
"rhythm," "theory and hearing") from the Caruthers School of Piano;
a "senior ticket" to Hyde Park High School's Junior Prom (which
took place at 8 p.m. on March 22 sometime in the early 1920s); there
is Camp Wewan-eeta's brochure, its cover autographed in a now faded
hand by camp co-director Eva Radzinski ("Hope we may have the joy
of having dear Irma with us again this year") and just inside is
the camp song, the first of whose many verses is,
"I
love Wewan-eeta,
Just think what we do.
There is weaving, tennis, quoits,
And we're good marksmen, too.
Quoits?
Above all,
there are the drawings of a girl who, from an early age, dreamed
of becoming a commercial artist and, some two decades later, in
World War II newspaper ads offering portraits in return for war-bond
purchases, would be identified as "New York's Girl Caricaturist."
There's her first published sketch, a playbill cover for a high
school production of "The Two Vagabonds," with a tiny "Irma Selz"
signature snuck in at page bottom. And there's her first appearance
in a newspaper, the Chicago Daily Tribune, on April 24, 1924,
in a comic strip called "Harold Teen," evidently about a young flapper
and her boyfriend.
The middle
box of the strip offers possible hairdos for the flapper ("the mop,"
"pineapple bob," "Sandwich Isle shingle," and "Anita Loos," among
others) with a tagline, "from sketches by Irma Madelon Selz," who
must then have been about 17 years old. Of "Madelon," which was
not her middle name, I know a little something, for even half a
century later my mother still found it more beautiful than her actual
"Madeline," and still wished her parents, about whom I know almost
nothing, had bestowed it on her.
If you hold
such an album and somewhere in most houses one certainly
exists it is hardly possible not to feel the sadness of loss.
This single album is, after all, what's left of the early part of
my mother's life. It's a story, wish, fantasy, organized, edited,
and summarized almost wordlessly by her, and yet no matter how gently
you hold the pages, there is no way to prevent the photos from cracking
off into the margins, leaving only bits of dried glue behind, while
placed on any surface it promptly sheds a tiny residue of black
paper ashes.
One could,
of course, simply experience this as a kind of pathos and
so fill the emotional space it creates with nostalgia for a lost
world. But in the disintegration of such everyday documents, packed
away on the top shelves of closets or in bottom drawers, in boxes
or garbage bags, worn attaché cases or old suitcases, attics, basements,
or garages, there is also an everyday fierceness that we seldom
consider.
It's the fierceness
of death, and of everything that's lost to us all the time, everything
the brain, even a well-functioning one, is incapable of holding.
It's the sense of, I think, borrowed time in this world, on this
planet. It's everything that, like that face inside mine, remains
difficult to swallow. But above all, it's the brief span of our
lives, as ephemeral as any set of digital photos.
Racing
the Bomb into the World
Thought of
another way, however, that familiar face embedded in mine offers
the chance for a little whirlwind double bio of the last century-plus.
In one merged face, he and I cover a span of history, of change,
carnage, and promise so unsettling that it, too, is almost impossible
to take in.
The son of
a poor immigrant who made good (but just for a while) in America,
my father was born in 1907. I have, on my wall, a photo of him at
perhaps age two, his older sister, in a white dress, a bow in her
hair, sitting beside him on a little bench, her arm proudly around
him. She faces the camera with the kind of intentness that went
with a slower photographic process. A big white house and trees
are behind them. This must be turn-of-the-century Flatbush in New
York's Brooklyn, where they grew up.
Perhaps because
the action snapshot had yet to arrive, everything seems remarkably
still. My father's hair is blond. (I, of course, mainly knew him
as a stocky, balding man with graying hair.) He wears a little Buster
Brownish outfit and long socks as well as what appears to be a halter
of bells (in case he wanders off?). Perched on that seat, he looks
tiny, fragile, and a bit dazed, something like a porcelain doll,
but nothing like my father. Nothing at all. I can find no
resemblance to the angry bull of a man who raged through the golden
1950s, as likely unemployed and drinking as anything else. Nor like
the prosperous salesman/businessman of the 1970s, nor the stroke-struck
elderly gent (with a mustache just like mine) with whom I spent
so much time in the early 1980s.
As I said,
he was not someone to dwell on the past. But he did once tell me
that he could still remember a man with a horse and cart pulling
up to his house with blocks of ice for what was then an actual "ice"
box. He was 11 when the War to End All Wars ended, and somewhere
I have a picture of him from that time in a little uniform. He could
remember buying charlottes russe (ladyfingers and Bavarian cream)
which, decades later out of nostalgia, he would pick up for
me from a local bakery off the back of a wagon on a street
near Erasmus High in Brooklyn where he went to school and played
lacrosse.
He was 22
when the stock market crashed in 1929 and he was working
doing what? I don't know for the Swift Meat Packing Company.
He was in his mid-twenties when the Nazis rose to power in Germany,
and our relatives (some of whom he would later help escape from
Austria) began, as Jews, to feel the heat.
In December
1941, at the age of 34, soon after the Japanese struck Pearl Harbor,
he volunteered for the U.S. Army Air Corps to fight the Nazis and
was sent to India as operations officer for the 1st Air Commando
Group, a glider outfit striking behind Japanese lines in Burma.
I have a photo of him in full uniform before he left, looking so
young and handsome and (a word I wouldn't normally associate with
him) vulnerable, with a not-quite-smile on his face. For the second
time in mere decades, a world war was underway, and this time it
would be so much more global and so much worse.
And here,
as the American wars in Europe and the Pacific were reaching a crescendo,
in July 1944, I the other half of that merged face
entered the picture, almost halfway through his life, only three
years after Henry Luce proclaimed his century the
American one. "Pops" to the men in his unit in a young man's
war, he was 37 years old, and had by then been reassigned to the
Pentagon. His son arrived just in time to celebrate the triumph
of American science and technology, the dawning of a new age.
In the race
to be born, I beat the atomic bomb into existence by almost a year.
It was first tested in the desert at White Sands Proving Ground
near Alamogordo, New Mexico, on July 16, 1945. I was born on July
20, 1944 at Lenox Hill Hospital in New York City, less than 13 months
before an A-bomb would leave the bomb bay of the Enola Gay
with "autographs and messages," some obscene, scribbled
on it by American soldiers, "greetings" to those about to die
and the last human acts of the pre-atomic age.
In an instant,
that new bomb would obliterate Hiroshima. And a few days later,
the atomic annihilation of Nagasaki would follow, raising the curtain
on the next war even before the War to End All Wars (redux) was
officially over (again).
A new war,
the third global one, this time fought by only two "superpowers,"
would be icier than the last two, restrained, ironically enough,
by what was then called "the unthinkable," the worst that science
could conjure up. It was, that is, restrained by the ability of
either superpower, after a time, to destroy not just humanity but
potentially the planet itself.
By the end
of 1945, American troops already occupied one half of the Korean
Peninsula, and Russian troops the other. Soon enough, the two nuclear-armed
superpowers would be going at it in the only way they could, given
the world-destroying weapons they possessed with bitter fury,
but by proxy and "in the shadows," inscribing their nightmare version
of a global war for domination on the bodies of Koreans, Vietnamese,
Laotians, Cambodians, Afghans, and others.
Dreams
and My Room
So the atomic
age was underway, an age of horror, but also of wonder. Already
in 1945, with the war still raging, Belmont Radio ("Today, Belmont's
job is to produce high-precision electronic equipment for the Armed
Forces...") was typical in offering a vision of a dazzling war-inspired
future as Belmont Television: "You can pull pictures from the air
as easily as you 'tune in' with your present radio... talking pictures
at television's best." The image that went with Belmont's ad showed
an impressive wooden cabinet perched atop which was a small screen
displaying a cowboy on a bucking bronco.
"[I]n these
days of tired bodies and troubled minds, it's good… to think about...
the new kind of a home you will have after victory," began a 1944
ad from General Electric, while General Motors ("Victory is our
business") swore in ad copy that it would "provide more and better
things for more people in the coming years of peace."
Indeed, for
the Third World War, aka the Cold War, the arms race and the race
for the good life were to be put on the same 24/7 "war" footing.
In the 1950s, all the promised big ticket items, including the "electric
refrigerator with ample space for everything, frozen foods included"
it had been but a few decades since that horse and cart with
ice had pulled up at my father's door and the "new automatic
clothes dryer" were to tumble into new American homes. These, not
any event in history, would become the agreed upon "landmarks" of
this age along with (soon enough) Mickey Mouse, the Golden Arches,
and the Swoosh. A military Keynesianism and its consumer doppelganger
would now drive the U.S. economy toward desire for the ever larger
car and missile, electric range and tank, television
console and submarine, all of which would be wedded in single
corporate entities, displaying their wares in your bedroom and selling
them in the labyrinthine corridors of the Pentagon.
Here was the
promise: From the ashes of war, new wonders would emerge
and so they did bountifully (as well, of course, as further ashes).
The buying of big-ticket and then not-so-big-ticket
items and the making of war with the most advanced technology around,
that was the dizzying story of my time (until a frazzled planet's
economic system began to melt down in the fall of 2008).
But you wouldn't
have known it from my room in the 1950s. In those years, after all,
the "teenager" was just being discovered by the corporation. I was
part of the first generation of American children who, if they had
jobs, as I did every summer from the age of 14 on, didn't have to
turn their money over to their families, the first to have more
than spare change in their pockets and to be able to choose where
to spend it.
I was, of
course, living in a country where, with the exception of Pearl Harbor,
and Attu and Kiska in the Aleutian
islands, there had been no fighting, no ashes at all. In 1945,
the United States loomed triumphantly untouched over a ruined planet,
and with perfect symbolism, two of that country's secretaries of
defense would, in the mid-1950s and again in the early 1960s, be
plucked from the presidencies of the great automakers. ("...I
thought what was good for the country was good for General Motors
and vice versa," GM President Charles Wilson told senators at his
confirmation hearings in 1953.)
The imperial
vistas of the 1950s were expansively vast and clean and in
the world of the child, looked at from the toy-stuffed, video-game
filled, hand-held, ear-glued techno-universe of the twenty-first
century, remarkably, sometimes even horribly, often boringly, empty,
like the sightlines Baron Haussman cleared on Paris's great boulevards
to gun down the mob. From the child's point of view, what's still
striking about that Golden Age of suburban consumerism was the relative
bareness of its interiors.
My own room
would seem spare indeed today for a "middle class" family, even
one like ours living deep in debt and beyond its means. My mother,
the artist, painted its walls with sprightly Mother Goose scenes
when I was tiny, and later with marching grenadiers, and there was
a bed, a chair, at some point a small desk, a lamp, a giant wooden
hand-me-down Philco radio, a few games, some books, my precious
toy soldiers, a toy six-gun with holster (cowboys were the craze
then), and by the end of that decade, a cheap record player for
45s (not that anyone now remembers what they were) each limited
and distinct purchase entering my life with its own special history,
its own familial price tag attached.
That Philco
was, for me, what we now call "the media," along with the newspapers
which then seemed like the lifeblood of the city, and as in so many
American houses, LIFE magazine. New York City was then a
riot of daily reportage. After all, it still had at least eight
or nine papers, and that already represented a loss in numbers.
The very names of some like the Journal American (the New
York American and the New York Evening Journal) or the
World-Telegram & Sun (the New York World, the Evening
Telegram, and the New York Sun) were amalgams of previously
independent papers. And the crucial thing in those childhood
years most of them had comics.
My favorite
board game growing up was "Star Reporter." I still remember the
little cards you picked that offered you, the potential star reporter,
ordinary stories, but also "disasters" and "catastrophes." And then,
having been assigned your story, with a role of the dice you left
the city of "Urbania" to cover it. In my spare time, I dreamed of
becoming a reporter a dream that, these days, looks as outmoded
as the desire to be an arctic explorer.
Here is what
I grew up reading:
- Cereal
boxes (I used to joke that I learned my ABCs off them otherwise
how could I send in the correct number of box tops and get the
"atomic rings" and "secret decoders" they offered?)
- comic strips
- comic books
(however, like many children in those years, I was forbidden from
buying "horror comics")
- real books
(from that radical resource, the library, where, if the librarian
let you out of the children's section, you had access to anything
in the adult world without having to invest a penny in it)
- MAD
magazine (after the "bad" comics went down in a 1950s childhood
version of an auto-da-fé)
- pulp sci-fi
(the more mutants the merrier)
- foreign
novels
(in my later teens)
The first
of those works of foreign fiction was Jorge Amado's Gabriella,
Clove and Cinnamon, which I stumbled upon in a tiny neighborhood
bookstore. I plunked down my money no small thing then
not because it was intriguingly foreign and I had a yen to explore,
but because each volume in its uniquely designed Avon Books paperback
series had rounded corners. I bought it with one mission in mind
to ensure that my classmates and others, noting the strangely
shaped book I was carrying around, would conclude that I was a far
odder and more interesting character than, in those days, I felt
I had any right to be, or was. So painfully straight, I desperately
wanted others to think I was, if not "cool," then at least just
a little "crazy" (a category gaining something of a cachet in those
days as hip-ness came into style among the young).
No one, of
course, ever noticed, but having that paperback in my hands, I naturally
read it, which is why since I kept on buying from the series
I've always said that it doesn't matter how you get to a
book, as long as you get there.
This, then,
was the way that, from the privacy of my relatively empty world,
in the financial capital of the globe's great, throbbing superpower,
I tried to sneak a few peeks, like that wonderful later children's
fictional character, Harriet the Spy, at a mysterious adult world
you couldn't access by clicking a remote to some "reality" show
or Oprah.
The Screen
and the Foreign Film
Perhaps the
most dizzying story of our time is the story of the multiplying
screen, which, when I was young, you still visited a special
moment outside the house at the movies. New Yorker
magazine film critic Pauline Kael once wrote a book entitled I
Lost It at the Movies. I know just what she meant, but my
own title would be the opposite. I found it life
there. It helped that, in the 1950s, I was living on, cinematically
speaking, the single strangest street in the United States. Within
five blocks, there were four movie houses, including the RKO where,
on any weekend day, you could see Merrill's
Marauders, To
Hell and Back, or The
Long Grey Line, and regularly experience in all its glory
the war my father wouldn't talk about.
Hollywood was,
as it remains, the unchallenged imperial capital of the movie world,
and yet the lives it displayed in its products, riveting as they
were, seemed somehow to have nothing to do with mine. The other
three movie houses The Paris, The Plaza, and The Fine Arts
were, however, what made that street unique. At a time and
in a country in which "foreign films" were essentially impossible
to find for thousands of miles in any direction, all three theaters
showed them. Subtitles, that was my life. I read at the movies,
too.
The manager
of The Plaza, who befriended me, used to let me sneak in. The
Rose Tattoo, Last
Year at Marienbad. I often had no idea what I was seeing
only that it invariably opened a window onto a world that
was amazingly alive, and amazingly unlike anything anyone told me
this world was, or should be, about. It was at the movies that I
learned about Hiroshima as a human catastrophe (Hiroshima
Mon Amour), the French War in Algeria (Sundays
and Cybele), the fact that Germans (The
Bridge), Japanese, and, above all, Red Rusky Commies (Ballad
of a Soldier) were actually living, breathing, struggling
human beings. Such a small, simple point that, at the time, seemed
anything but.
Somehow, those
films collectively reassured me that, beyond the empty vistas of
childhood that left kids like me wondering when, if ever, our lives
would actually begin, lay life itself, even if, in all its bizarre,
pretentious, thrilling, moving everydayness, it seemed only to be
lived by foreigners. Those movies were my escape. They saved my
life. Plenty of other American kids weren't so lucky.
In those years,
of course, the screen entered the house as something inescapable
and would, in the decades to come, begin to multiply. If the TV
had first landed on the lawn or (in my case) the street, it would
have been clear enough that it was an invader. But that purveyor
of all things commercial made a soft landing directly in the comfortable
living room, only then heading for the bedroom, previously the most
private of spaces, which would now be attached to the most public
and visual of selling spectacles.
Remembering
the exact moment it entered my house April 1953 I
once wanted to write an essay called "Thank God for Senator McCarthy!"
In that spring, my mother was doing political caricatures for the
New York Post, then a liberal tabloid, which assigned her
to draw the Army-McCarthy Hearings, about to be shown in the afternoons
on ABC.
So, we finally
got the TV for which I had been begging fruitlessly all the previous
year. It was a major moment in my young life and the Senator's iconic
face was so less-than-reliable memory assures me the
first image I saw on a TV screen in my own house. The truth was
I found him unsurprising. With those jowls and that pugnacious,
in-your-face face, he looked to me like half the fathers I knew,
including my own. Me? I wanted to raise a cheer for the infamous
senator, who got me off the TV blacklist. After all, he brought
me Disney ("When you wish upon a star..."), and Lucy, and Ed Sullivan.
Soon enough,
he was gone, but TV was forever.
Conspiracies
Large and Small
As in the
original meaning of the word "conspire" to breathe the same
air we conspire in the realities we breathe in. No wonder
we so often can't see them for what they turn out to be.
Until recently,
our world looked so easy, so stable. A two-party world. No one imagined
that the world my father and mother lived through, that of the Great
Depression, could sneak back on stage for another bow. A year ago,
had I told you that a former Clinton-era secretary of labor was
going to write a piece headlined
"When Will the Economic Recovery Begin? Never.," you would have
laughed.
Now, we know.
Our reality, like that of our last president, was distinctly inside
the bubble, while the world out there was so much fiercer, so much
less tame than we imagined.
Let's face
it. It's been a dizzying journey, these last hundred years, so much
odder than we imagine. We don't have a picture of it yet. Not really.
We're still waiting for the face of the past the actual face
to appear in a mirror, or on one of those many screens of
our lives, to tell us where we've really been, and where we may
really be going.
Surprises
abound. For 65 years, my face lacked my father, at least when I
looked, anyway. Now, entering my 66th year, he's back to take another
bow and that you'll have to take my word for it is
fierce.
And here I
am, well beyond any point I was capable of imagining when young.
That's fierce too, especially when your life, no matter how you
look at it, is so much closer to death than is truly comfortable.
It's been
a dizzying trip so far. Screens are now everywhere you turn
in bars, airports, taxis, on gas pumps, in restaurants, hair salons,
your new car, your doctor's office, in your pocket, in the street,
and in your home in multiple ways and you're often attached
to them, not them to you. People check their screens and then take
phone calls at your dinner table. The young, while sitting in restaurants
not talking to each other, text friends in distant places.
In the meantime,
the newspaper, that lifeline of my childhood, is in the media ER
on life support. It's amazing to think that the print newspaper-reading
habit, passed down from parent to child, is now following the typewriter
out the door and into oblivion. Meanwhile, for the first time in
our world, a new reading habit, the online one, is being passed
upward from child to parent.
We grew up
imagining the newspaper as primarily a purveyor of the news, and
pundits still write about it that way, regularly bemoaning the potential
"loss" of a pillar of the American democratic system. But looked
at in a fiercer way, everything about the present moment tells us
that was never the real story.
It's clearer
now that the newspaper as we knew it was, first and foremost, a
purveyor of ads. That, not the news, was what actually mattered,
which should be apparent to anyone who bothers, for instance, to
glance at the anorexic Sunday New York Times Magazine. Like
the Incredible Shrinking Man of 1950s sci-fi, it's disappearing
right before our eyes. Ads fleeing the premises take journalists,
bureaus, meaning, the news itself, the paper, everything, with them.
It was a small
flap, the recent one at the Washington Post, in which publisher
Katharine Weymouth was to host "salons" at her house, offering corporations
and lobbyists off-the-record, non-confrontational "access" to Post
reporters, Obama administration officials, and Congressional representatives.
At $25,000 a pop, corporations could get a seat at these friendly
soirées, $250,000
for a package of 11. The stern, tsk-tsking discussions of this attempt
to pull a little extra dough into a dying brand have all focused
on newspaper "ethics" the Post's own ombudsman referred
to the to-do as "an ethical lapse of monumental proportions."
In the meantime,
a striking aspect of the brouhaha has gone uncommented upon. Weymouth
(or, at least, the sales side of the paper) was offering full-frontal
access at only $25,000 per salon. That's chump change for a big
health corporation, or Exxon, or a major lobbyist. It would be like
tossing a few coins to a beggar. If her grandmother, Post
publisher Katherine Graham, had offered a similar deal and
that, of course, would have been inconceivable in an era when the
ads in the pages of the paper were still thick as thieves
imagine the value she might have put on a night of her time and
the Post's influence. Not $25,000, you can be sure of that.
The
world reveals itself to us in its own sweet time, just as my father
waited all these years after his death on Pearl Harbor Day 1983
to remind me that I'm his child as indeed I am and
that I was shaped by his world as indeed I was. A world of
war and suffering, of wonder and ashes. It's also a reminder that
our pictures of how life works can develop late indeed.
Who knows
when you'll glance into a mirror and meet a past you hadn't expected
and weren't ready for. Or a future for that matter. After all, that
can happen, too. You're passing, as usual, through our land of screens
and war, driven by ads and companies that were so sure until yesterday
that the arms race and the good life could be melded in them forever
and a day, when suddenly the
planes appear, the skyscrapers begin to tumble, everything that's
ordinary and accepted begins to unravel. As it could. All those
screens, all connected, and all the texts that go with them, everything
we count on. It could go.
If you care
to look, you can see the outlines, the shorelines, of our world
changing even as I write this. For the future, "dizzying" might
hardly be the word.
Look in the
mirror and tell me what you see.
July
21, 2009
Tom
Engelhardt [send him mail]
co-founder
of the Nation Institute's TomDispatch.com, is the co-founder of
the American Empire
Project. His book, The
End of Victory Culture, has recently been updated in a newly
issued edition. He edited, and his work appears in, the first best
of TomDispatch book, The
World According to TomDispatch: America in the New Age of Empire
(Verso), an alternative history of the mad Bush years. To catch
an audio interview in which he discusses our airborne assassins,
click here.
Copyright
© 2009 Tom Engelhardt
The
Best of Tom Engelhardt
|