Pity
the Poor Rich
by
Bill Bonner
by
Bill Bonner
Recently by Bill Bonner:
The Extraordinary
Evil of Bernie Madoff
We begin our
week with a quote from our favorite philosopher: Yu Faz.
The rich
mans heart breaks
just like the poor mans. For
all his money, he cannot buy another one.
Yu should know.
He was exiled after he had a liaison amoureuse with one of Genghis
concubines.
Pity poor Yu!
Pity the poor rich
! As long-term sufferers know, we always
take the part of the underdog. We almost never saw a lost cause
that we didnt want to join. We admire die-hards
and we
like the company of scalawags.
So, today,
we take up the banner of one group that is all these things
a
group that is widely despised and routinely persecuted
the
“untouchables” at the top of the economic pyramid: the rich.
Switzerland
at war with the rest of the world, begins an update from colleague,
Cecile Chevre, in Paris.
The Swiss usually
manage to stay out of wars. They do it by being heavily armed. Even
the yodelers have softened up lately, but until recently every able-bodied
man was required to serve in the Swiss Army. He had to keep his
rifle at home
and each year he had to prove that he knew how
to use it.
During WWII,
the Germans considered invading Switzerland. According to legend,
a top German general met with Switzerlands top military man
on the border.
We have
twice as many men on the border as you do, said the German.
What would you do if we launched an attack?
The answer
is very obvious, replied the Swiss general. I would
tell each of my men to shoot twice.
But now Switzerland
is up against even worse odds. Switzerland has long been a haven
for people with money. And life is getting tougher for the rich
as
well as for those who defend them.
In the first
place, getting rich is not as easy as it used to be. Gone are the
days when you could just put your money in the market
and come back 10 years later with 10 times as much. If you had invested
$70,000 in Dow stocks in 82 and let it grow, youd have
been a millionaire by 2007
Even after inflation, investors
came out way ahead.
Gone too are
the glory days in real estate, too. How many fortunes in America
were built on dirt? Thousands of them
maybe millions. Especially,
in places such as California, Florida and Las Vegas
a steady
immigration over decades produced a bonanza for property owners.
A fellow of modest means was able to mortgage his house and buy
more properties. He might begin with the house across the street
and
then buy four condo units down the road
and then move on to
major apartment buildings and commercial property too. After a couple
of decades, he could easily have parlayed a few thousand of original
equity into millions worth of property assets.
But how do
you do that when prices are falling? And when lenders no longer
want to give you credit? We received a letter recently, from a fellow
with a string of properties in Las Vegas. He had bought wisely and
now enjoyed positive cash flow after all costs, including
financing. Still, he couldnt find a lender willing to roll
over his debt.
The last couple
of years have been a bad time to be rich. The capitalists
capital is capitulating. Its giving up and dying.
Meanwhile,
governments are looking to the rich to finance their
bailout programs, their wars, their pension programs and giveaways.
Where else can they look? They need money. Like Willie Sutton, they
know where the money is.
A few years
ago too, the rabble-rousers made the news by pointing to the uneven
distribution of wealth in America. Eighty-five percent of
the wealth in the country was owned by only 20% of the people What
got people chafed was that the rich were getting richer. The percentage
of total wealth owned by the rich had gone up from 81% in 1983.
What happened
in the years 83 to 2004 to make the rich so much richer? Financial
assets rose in value.
And then what
happened? Financial assets fell in value in 0709.
The total amount lost, according to the latest number we saw, is
about $13 trillion. Roughly, both houses and stocks are down about
a third. Who took those losses? The poor? Ha ha. The nice thing
about being poor is that you dont have to worry about losing
money in a downturn. No, dear reader, the poor are scarcely poorer
because of the slump. They had nothing when it began; they still
have nothing. The rich, on the other hand, were big-time losers.
They must have borne 85% of the losses or a total of about
$10 trillion. If thats correct, the rich must now own a smaller
piece of the pie than any time in the last 25 years.
We feel a tear
forming in our right eye. There
it wells up
and rolls
down over our trembling cheek. The poor rich!
The rich in
America may have lost $10 trillion so far
but their losses
are just beginning. Whos going to pay the expenses of bailing
out the banks
the economy
the states
Detroit
?
You do the
math yourself. The United States functions as a popular democracy.
Politicians get elected by winning votes. The idea is to get as
many votes as possible. Do you get the most votes by appealing to
the few people with money the 20% rich? Or do
you appeal to the masses the 80% of the population who dont
have much wealth?
Well, you can
do the math later.
How do you
get the masses to vote for you? You offer them something. What?
Well
Medicare
pensions
bridges
tax credits
wars
whatever they seem to want at the moment. And how do you
pay for it?
Okay
now
were putting 2 and 2 together: you have to take the money
from therich.
Of course,
its not that simple. Because you also need money from the
rich to get the word out about what a great guy you
are. And if you lose the race for the House of Representatives,
you want to make sure you have a cushy chair somewhere to rest your
fat behind. No point in going to the masses for those things. You
need friends among the rich.
So, you favor
some of the rich with special subsidies and credits
while making the rest of them pay. And since youre competing
with other politicians who have gotten their support from other
groups of rich people
at the end of the day, by the time the
votes are counted, its hard to know exactly who the real winners
and losers are. One rich family gets millions in subsidies. Another
has his business protected from competition. Another benefits from
an obscure amendment to an almost unknown little section of the
IRS code. Rivals get wind of these boondoggles and make a stink
about it in the press. Pretty soon, the masses think the rich
are ripping them off
not realizing that, as a group, the rich
pay for 80% of the costs of government.
And now, as
the official federal debt goes to $12 trillion, whos really
going to pay it? Just apply the 80/20 rule
the rich
will have to pay 80% of it at least. Thats $9.6 trillion
that will be borne by 60 million citizens. No, wait
of those
60 million
you have to take out those who are too young
or
too old. Each household may only have one person earning a living
say,
only about 20 million real taxpayers.
Now, divide
$9.6 trillion by 20 million you get a debt burden of $480,000
for each one.
But thats
just the official national debt, which is bad enough.
But what about Social Security and healthcare obligations
and
obligations to soldiers whove lost their legs in Iraq? Are
you going to forget about these people? Whos going to support
them?
According to
the Petersen Foundation, theres a financing gap
of about $47 trillion between what the government is obliged to
pay out and what it expects to get in tax revenues. Now, lets
put that burden too onto the only place it might be shouldered
the same 20% of the population who have the money the rich
people. Thats another $2.35 million per taxpayer!
And
now you see why Switzerland is at war with the world.
Almost all the worlds governments are running large deficits;
all are squeezing the rich. Switzerland is the place rich
people turn to when they want to protect their money from greedy
politicians. It got its start in the 17th century, back when Louis
XIV revoked the Edict of Nantes. Suddenly Protestants werent
allowed to live in peace in France. Many fled to England, America
and the Low countries. Others sent their money offshore
to Switzerland, where it would be safe from confiscation. Thus did
Switzerland develop its banking industry to help protect
people from their own governments.
And thus do
people turn to the Swiss once again, as they see their own governments
sharpening their knives and tightening their borders. In order to
preserve its role as a protector of foreigners money, Switzerland
has been forced to resist these measures. Major Swiss banks, for
example, announced that they would no longer be available to American
clients. Too much paperwork; too much disclosure. And since Swiss
law prevents bankers from divulging details of their clients
accounts, the Swiss are in a jam. If they failed to report to the
United States, theyd be breaking US law. If they did report
to the US, theyd be breaking Swiss law.
Swiss bankers
just sent a letter to their French clients
asking for permission
to pass along information about their accounts to the French government.
What
sort of Frenchman would give his okay? asks Cecile. Sure,
denounce me to the French taxmen
rat me out, go ahead.
But the banks were forced to send out the letter in order to comply
with French demands.
July
7,
2009
Bill
Bonner [send
him mail] is the author, with Addison Wiggin, of Financial
Reckoning Day: Surviving the Soft Depression of The 21st
Century and
Empire of Debt: The Rise Of An Epic Financial Crisis and
the co-author with Lila Rajiva of Mobs,
Messiahs and Markets (Wiley, 2007).
Copyright
© 2009 Bill Bonner
The
Best of Bill Bonner
|