Running
Out of Money
by
Bill Bonner
by Bill Bonner
DIGG THIS
Yesterday brought
news that Toyota sells more automobiles in America than Ford does.
But nothing to worry about, say economists, soothingly.
Of course,
we agree; it is nothing to worry about. Like approaching death.
You are far better off maintaining a serene outlook. Besides, it
is summertime. We do not worry about things in the summer. There
is plenty of time to fret in the autumn, winter and spring. Summer
is a time for insouciance.
Still, we find
that Ford has lost even more than expected in the last quarter –
$254 million. And no chance of making it up on volume; those SUVs
aren't selling, despite all the discounts and incentives.
We don't know
how Toyota does it, but it looks to us as though U.S. consumers
are slowly running out of money – just as we guessed they would.
"Mortgage default
notices soar 67%," says the LA Times.
Starbucks stock
has fallen 23% in the last 30 days. "Service sector activity cools
in July," adds CBS Marketwatch. "Gas costs eat into restaurant sales,"
runs another headline.
A new friend,
Dennis Gartman, tells us that the economy is definitely headed into
a recession that will take stocks down 15% to 20%. He sees a kind
of "stagflation light" infecting U.S. markets.
We also see
stagflation, but light or heavy...we refuse to worry about it until
September.
Meanwhile,
the central banks are playing a dangerous game. They're trying to
exterminate the "flation" part without letting the stag part get
out of hand. The Bank of England made another move to the upside
this week – raising rates to 4.75%. England, like America, has an
economy that depends on a lot on marginal consumers, who depend
on a marginal property market that depends on low borrowing rates...that
are set by the banks. At some point, adding straws to our groaning
camel's back, 25 basis points at a time, they are going to find
the one that brings the critter to the ground. But only after they've
laid it on. Then, they'll have the stag to worry about; the "flation"
will have disappeared.
"But how is
it possible," a man asked us in Vancouver, "to have deflation, when
the Feds are all pushing money into the system as if they were shoving
commuters onto the Tokyo subway."
We offer him
our standard explanation: "What happens is that the means of pushing
money and credit into the financial system break down," we say.
"This is what happened in Japan in the 1990s. The Japanese cut rates
to zero. The government borrowed money. The government spent money
(it undertook so many public works projects that at one point, the
small island nation poured more concrete than all of the United
States). But the magic had vanished. As consumers saw the economy
collapsing, they became very frugal. They wouldn't spend and they
wouldn't borrow. Eventually, the authorities couldn't get any money
into the system and prices went down. And then, as prices went down,
consumers held back even more, because they knew that if they waited,
they could get an even better deal."
Not that we're
worried about any of this. We're as tranquil and content as a frog
by a mill pond. But we still have our eyes open. And what we see
is an economy stalling like a jet out of fuel. Will it be a light
landing? Or a hard one? We don't know, but the risk is that it will
come down with a smack.
Next week,
the Fed meets again to fix the price of short-term credit. After
a long series of "baby step" increases, the Fed has walked into
the specter of stagflation. It can raise rates again to fight inflation.
But it risks breaking the economy's feeble credit-stiffened backbone.
Ben Bernanke
reads the headlines, too. He's made a career of watching the Japanese
struggle to get out of deflation. He knows how hard it is to resurrect
the camel of a consumer economy after it has buckled at the knees.
When the time comes to speak up at the next rate-fixing meeting
– next week – our guess is that Mr. Bernanke will have lost his
voice...and maybe his nerve.
And back at
Ouzilly...
• OK, the United
States may no longer be able to make it in the car business, but
we're still number one at finance, right? When it comes to shuffling
money, nobody does it better.
But what's
this?
"Wall Street
and Washington are fretting that many of the world's biggest initial
public offerings are taking place on exchanges in London, Hong Kong,
and Shanghai – and not in New York," says a Slate news item.
"There is no
single reason why IPOs are heading overseas...But as Alan Murray
suggests in the Wall Street Journal...Americans are also losing
our IPO advantage because we're not as good at them anymore. A report
by Oxera Consulting, which the London Stock Exchange and the City
of London commissioned, found that the United States – for reasons
that have little to do with Sarbanes-Oxley – is more expensive and
not particularly efficient at IPOs."
U.S. investment
banks are too expensive; there's too much red tape and too many
lawyers. Companies no longer need to list their shares in the United
States in order to get U.S. investors.
Yes, now even
the money shufflers are being outsourced.
• What's the
latest from Zimbabwe? We ask because we always feel that Zimbabwe
gives us a hint of what is in store. At 1,200%, inflation in the
pitiable African country is the highest in the world. But this week,
the central bank of Zimbabwe took steps "to help commerce and everyday
life." What it did was to take three zeros off the currency. The
U.S. dollar, formerly quoted at 250,000 Zimbabwean dollars, is now
quoted at only 250. You can see what a great convenience this is
to consumers. Instead of paying a million dollars for a loaf of
bread, henceforth they will pay only 1,000. At least this week.
Next week they may be back to paying more.
Gideon Gono,
governor of the Reserve Bank of Zimbabwe, went on TV on Monday to
address the nation:
"Our
currency is in trouble," he announced gravely. "Our people are experiencing
incredible hardships and inconveniences associated with too many
zeros."
Yes, that's
it...hit the nail squarely on the head, Mr. Gono. Give it a whack.
But whence cometh all these troublesome zeros? Robert Mugabe, the
democratically elected chief of state, lays the blame on "enemies"
– both domestic and external.
So,
off with the damned zeros! Nothing could be simpler.
How's that
for summer entertainment, dear reader?
August
5, 2006
Bill
Bonner [send
him mail] is the author, with Addison Wiggin, of Financial
Reckoning Day: Surviving the Soft Depression of The 21st
Century and
Empire of Debt: The Rise Of An Epic Financial Crisis.
Copyright
© 2006 Bill Bonner
Bill
Bonner Archives
|