Editor’s Note: San Francisco is taking a page out of New York’s Vision Zero playbook by considering dropping the speed limit in the city to 20 mph. The measure, proposed by San Francisco Supervisor Eric Mar, would be one of a number of command-and-control policies ostensibly designed to reduce the city’s pedestrian and bicycle fatalities to zero by 2024.The misguided Vision Zero movement originated in Sweden and moved to New York with the election of Mayor de Blasio. For more on Vision Zero, check out this e-newsletter.
NMA E-Newsletter #262: Vision Zero Equals Zero Vision
Against the State: An ... Best Price: $5.02 Buy New $5.52 (as of 11:35 EST - Details) Former New York City Mayor Michael Bloomberg was never a friend of the motorist. He famously stated his desire to put red-light cameras “on every corner” and led the charge to bring speed cameras to the five boroughs.
However, his zeal for “traffic safety” pales in comparison to that of his successor, The Honorable Bill de Blasio. During his campaign, de Blasio outlined his “Vision Zero” initiative which seeks to eliminate all traffic fatalities from the streets of New York in 10 years.
Apparently he wasn’t kidding and has vowed to fulfill that campaign promise. Vision Zero calls for the usual complement of traffic safety interventions:
- Road “improvements” including narrower streets, wider sidewalks and medians, and more bicycle lanes
- Quadrupling the number of 20-mph slow zones throughout the city A Government of Wolves... Best Price: $1.16 Buy New $2.99 (as of 10:15 EST - Details)
- Stepped-up traffic enforcement particularly for speeding and failure to yield
- Expansion of the city’s nascent speed-camera program
The goal of eliminating all traffic fatalities is of course completely unrealistic, and every stakeholder in the traffic safety community knows it. Why? Because people are people, and people make mistakes. Safety improvements are always possible, but not through the command-and-control, vehicle-hostile tactics the plan calls for. Vision Zero is nothing more than political theater as well as a tool to escalate the assault on driving.
Another safety initiative with the goal of eliminating all traffic fatalities comes from Sweden. Coincidentally, it’s also called Vision Zero and grew out of a partnership between the Swedish government and Swedish business interests.
With its motto, “In every situation a person might fail. The road system should not,” Vision Zero Swedish edition at least acknowledges the human element but conveys the belief that human fallibility can be overcome with enough intervention. Here’s more from the website:
Transport systems are traditionally designed for maximum capacity and mobility, not safety. This means road users are held responsible for their own safety. The Vision Zero Initiative takes the opposite approach. We place the main burden for safety on system design because we recognise human weaknesses and low tolerance to mechanical force. Ultimately, no one should die or suffer serious injury in traffic.
Suicide Pact: The Radi... Best Price: $0.25 Buy New $2.84 (as of 04:15 EST - Details)
Progressivism: A Prime... Best Price: $8.99 Buy New $10.95 (as of 08:30 EST - Details)
Real Dissent: A Libert... Best Price: $8.48 Buy New $7.93 (as of 03:10 EST - Details)