Orange County's best source for local information Sunday
Feb. 8, 2004
COAST: 71° Forecast Ocean
INLAND: 71° Traffic Surf
SUBSCRIBE TODAY
CUSTOMER SERVICE
OCRegister.comOC Car FinderOC Job FinderOC Real Estate Findermyoc.comOCExcelsior.com
or Browse by day
REGISTER ARCHIVES
Marketplace
Classified ads
Newspaper ads
Buy our photos
Coupons
Daily deals
Personals
Sections
 E-REGISTER
 The print edition online
 E-REGISTER ARCHIVE
 HOME PAGE
 REGISTER TOP NEWS
 BUSINESS
 COLUMNS
 COMMENTARY
 EDUCATION
 ENTERTAINMENT
 FOOD & WINE
 HEALTH & FAMILY
 HOME & GARDEN
 INVESTIGATIONS
 LIFE, ETC.
 LOCAL
 MULTIMEDIA
 NATION & WORLD
 OBITUARIES
 REGION & STATE
 SPECIAL FEATURES
 SPORTS
 TRAVEL
 WEATHER
Community news
Noticias en Espaņol
Interactive tools
Discussion boards
Financial tools
Get a map
Get directions
Make this my
home page
Movie times
Traffic
Yellow pages
Information
About us
Advertise with us
Contact us
Customer service
Register in education
Site feedback
Subscribe today
Media partners
MSNBC
OCExcelsior.com
myOC.com
KPCC
KOCE
COMMENTARY
Sunday, February 8, 2004

Fat and unhappy
Why does modern America look like Dickens' England to striking grocery workers in Southern California and Democratic presidential candidates on the campaign trail?

Illustration by Jocelyne Leger, The Register

RELATED LINKS
More columns by Steven Greenhut
By STEVEN GREENHUT
Senior editorial writer and columnist,
The Orange County Register
sgreenhut@ocregister.com

It's a funny thing how different people can live in the same place and see the world in entirely different ways. I wake up every morning in a country that strikes me as astoundingly wealthy, a place where people have more money than good sense.

But I listen to local union representatives and grocery strikers - and especially the Democratic presidential candidates - and I'm left thinking that America is one step above Calcutta.

I don't get it.

"Today, under George W. Bush, there are two Americas, not one: One America that does the work, another America that reaps the reward," said Sen. John Edwards, the multimillionaire trial lawyer who has made class warfare the centerpiece of his presidential campaign.

Really?

As I see it, people here aren't just well-nourished, they are overweight, victims of having so much cheap food at their beck and call that they can't control themselves. I'm not making fun of my fellow citizens, given that I am incapable of driving past Carl's Jr. without stopping for a Famous Star, but I am observing reality.

Everywhere I go, I see other people just like me - a little pudgy, wearing nice clothing, driving late-model cars, living in nice houses, eating at good restaurants, planning their next weekend at the beach or mountains, shopping for discount airline tickets, filling Sam's Club shopping carts with gadgets and delicacies that are the envy of the world.

This isn't life among the elite, but life among average folk. The shopping centers always are busy, and that's not because there is any shortage of them. I live within a few miles of seven home improvement warehouses. You can't sneeze without driving by another upscale shopping mall.

My neighborhood of well-kept older tract houses isn't home to the rich and famous, but mainly to middle-class people who work in a variety of blue-collar and midlevel white-collar jobs. Many of my neighbors are immigrants or the sons and daughters of immigrants, and almost all of them are homeowners, not renters.

Isn't this evidence of the American dream? Is this really a land of destitution, where only a tiny elite are living comfortably?

I've lived in older, rust-belt cities where factories have closed. My wife is from a coal- mining town in Appalachia. I am well-aware of the poorer neighborhoods around us. But even in these less-affluent places, I see nothing but well-fed, nicely dressed people awash in the sort of amenities unimaginable decades ago.

Just for fun, drive to the most modest neighborhood you can find and look at the newer cars, minivans and SUVs in the driveways or on the street and you'll see what I'm talking about.

Now I understand that there really are people going through hard times. I don't mean to gloss over that fact or dismiss their plight. But that's mainly what today's class warriors claim to see. They see only a world where the rich always are screwing the poor, an America that is divided between the haves and have-nots. They ignore how middle class most of us are, the opportunities that exist to start businesses, get an education and get good jobs, and the top-notch health care almost all of us receive.

The ongoing grocery dispute centers on whether well-compensated, low-skill stockers and checkers (who earn as much as $50 an hour on weekends) should have to contribute $5 to $15 a week in health care costs. The unions depict this as a fight between Robber Barons and Suffering Workers. I've crossed enough grocery picket lines recently to see workers unloading strike signs out of $40,000 SUVs. It's hard to feel more than the slightest pang of sympathy for them.

The union members love to criticize their employers, urging us, as shoppers, to go somewhere else, as if the employee's future is improved by harming the company that pays his bills. As ABC's John Stossel noted at a recent Orange County Forum luncheon, Americans hate their employers, who pay them, but love the government, which takes one-third of their income. Figure that one out.

Union members rail against Wal-Mart, as if Wal-Mart has put a gun to anyone's head to make one shop or work there. They compare all of corporate America to Enron executives. But companies - unlike the government and unions, which base their power on force rather than choice - get ahead by offering the best-possible goods at the lowest-possible prices. Rip-off artists like those execs at Enron generally end up bankrupt and in jail.

Yet Democratic front-runner John Kerry thinks otherwise. His economic program is based on punishing corporate wrongdoers, as if they typify the economic system.

But no one has the rhetoric down like Edwards: "One America that pays the taxes, another America that gets the tax breaks. One America that will do anything to leave its children a better life, another America that never has to do a thing because its children are already set for life. ..."

I'm practically wiping tears from my eyes as I write. Seriously, doesn't the good senator realize that the dreaded rich people, who create the jobs and build businesses, pay the lion's share of the taxes, which explains why most voters support "more programs" if they are paid for by "the rich"? The top 1 percent of earners pays 36 percent of the nation's income taxes.

Edwards is a smart guy. He knows the truth. He also knows how to appeal to base instincts to win votes.

So does state Attorney General Bill Lockyer. Speaking to 14,000 union members in Inglewood last month, he announced a state lawsuit against Ralphs, Vons and Albertsons because of a revenue-sharing deal the three companies have arranged during the strike.

The federal courts have allowed such deals, just as they allow similar deals by unions. Yet Lockyer - in a move that undermines any pretense of fairness in the state's administration of justice - declares, "This kind of corporate misbehavior breeds acts of revolutionary outrage."

Revolutionary outrage?

That's right, let's shut down these evil corporations and then the union workers can work for ... oops, there's the rub. Well, I hear the government always is hiring.

By almost any standard, America is a wealthy land with abundant opportunity for anyone willing to work hard and invest in their future. No place will ever be utopia, so the poor will always be with us. I don't close my eyes to them. I've written about the poor living in Anaheim motels and about the Catholic Worker homeless shelter. Sometimes people need help.

But the road from poverty to the middle class is well-trodden, provided individuals work hard, go to school and eschew government dependency and certain bad behaviors (drug addiction, teen pregnancy, crime).

I'm no fan of federal programs. But those who gauge America's compassion by its willingness to spend tax dollars on social programs have got to quit acting as if this is Dickens' England. The top two federal spending items are Health and Human Services ($571.6 billion) and Social Security ($555 billion), and both of those (FY 2005) budgets are increasing significantly under the "heartless" Bush administration.

Yet the facts never matter to the class warriors. There always are those people who refuse to see the many blessings they have, preferring to cast their eyes greedily toward their neighbors. And there are always politicians eager to exploit such feelings.

H.L. Mencken was right. Every election is an advance auction of stolen goods. But I think even he would be shocked at the disconnect between the rhetoric and the reality.


CONTACT US: sgreenhut@ocregister.com or (714) 796-7823
Welcome, egarris2!
ADVERTISING
Copyright 2004 The Orange County Register | Privacy policy | User agreement
Freedom communications Freedom Communications, Inc.