Who
Speaks for the American Military on Iraq?
by
William Marina
by William Marina
DIGG THIS
The bias in
the way in which the Media has covered the emerging presidential
campaign has been evident for some months now.
The implication
has been that a hawk like Rudy Giuliani speaks for the American
soldiers and other military members, when he, John McCain, Fred
Thompson and others, continue to parrot the Bush Administration’s
line that the US must "stay the course in Iraq," as withdrawal
would be a betrayal of our heroic fighting men and women.
The Media has
given short shrift to Ron Paul, the only candidate among the Republicans
who argues for withdrawal.
If that logic
was correct, then Ron Paul must be the most hated of the candidates
among those people associated with the US Military. But, is that
true?
Given the means
of electronic voting today, if the Bush Administration had the intestinal
fortitude to do so, that hypothesis could readily be tested. The
GOP was certainly keen to count the Military’s votes in the disputed
election in Florida during the 2000 election.
Is there some
alternative means of ascertaining the feelings of our Military with
respect to the candidates and their views? As it happens, perhaps
there is!
Few would argue
that in politics, people and interest groups tend to put their money
where their mouth is. That is, they give money to those candidates
whose views reflect their own interests.
That being
the case, the latest information we have about party donations is
quite interesting!
Analyzing the
latest finance reports, military-support for the Republican candidates,
The
Spin Factor broke down the donations from the Army, Navy,
Air Force, and among Veterans (their figures do not include the
Marines, which only slightly alters the results). The results can
be easily verified by checking the reports by employer for Ron
Paul and the
other candidates.
| Name |
Total
$
|
Army
|
Navy
|
AF
|
Vets
|
| Paul |
23,465
|
6,975
|
6,765
|
4,650
|
5,075
|
| McCain |
15,825
|
6,925
|
6,305
|
1,795
|
800
|
| Romney |
3,551
|
2,051
|
0
|
1,500
|
0
|
| Giuliani |
2,320
|
1,450
|
370
|
250
|
250
|
| Hunter |
1,000
|
0
|
1,000
|
0
|
--
|
| Huckabee |
750
|
250
|
0
|
500
|
--
|
| Tancredo |
350
|
350
|
0
|
0
|
--
|
| Brownback |
71
|
71
|
0
|
0
|
--
|
| Thompson |
0
|
0
|
0
|
0
|
--
|
*Note: The
numbers for the last five candidates have not been thoroughly verified.
52.53%: Ron Paul
35.4%: McCain
7.9%: Romney
5.2%: Giuliani
2.2%: Hunter
2.6%: Others
Thus, more
than half of the Military and Veterans donating funds to the Republican
Party candidates gave their monies to one candidate, Dr. Ron Paul.
I would suggest
this is about a clear an indication of the views of our Military
on the positions of the Republican candidates as we are apt to get.
Why doesn’t the Media offer this data to the American people?
July
19, 2007
William
Marina [send him mail]
is Professor Emeritus in History at Florida Atlantic University,
a Research Fellow of the Independent
Institute, Oakland, CA, and Executive Director of the Marina-Huerta
Educational Foundation. He lives in Asheville, NC.
Copyright
© 2007 LewRockwell.com
William
Marina Archives
|