Great Anti-War Films
Australian film director Peter Weir, perhaps best known to American
audiences for Witness
Truman Show, was planning his next film after completing
at Hanging Rock (1975), he wanted a story set in France
depicting the big battles of 1916-1917. A friend suggested he make
a film about the Australian and New Zealand Army Corps (ANZAC) attack
on Gallipoli. Unconvinced, he nevertheless traveled to Istanbul
in 1976. After spending two days climbing the hills and wandering
the trenches, Weir was struck by what he found: buttons, old leather
belts and other items left behind by ANZAC forces. He decided then
and there that he would indeed make a film about Gallipoli, saying,
"I felt somehow I was really touching history."
original idea was to tell a comprehensive story from enlistment
in 1914 though the evacuation of Gallipoli near the end of 1915,
but after several drafts, he was unhappy with the results. Instead,
he decided to write a tale about two friends and their journey to
war. The result is the outstanding anti-war film Gallipoli
Hamilton (Mark Lee is his debut role) is one of the best sprinters
in Australia, trained by his Uncle Jack (Bill Kerr). When he expresses
a desire to join the army and fight against Turkey in World War
I, his sage uncle protests vehemently:
No more of that. Youíre under age.
You ran away from home when you were younger than me.
Not to a war.
Been all around the world by the time you were eighteen: Barbary
Coast, Spice Islands.
I made most of those stories up.
No you didnít. Dad said you nearly got yourself killed half
a dozen times.
I judged the risks and took my chances. Warís different.
Howís it different.
ITíS JUST DIFFERENT!
has been training for a big race and has a goal to beat the time
of his hero Harry Lasalles, world-record holder in the 100-yard
dash. He ties his idol and then turns his attention to an army recruiter
for the Lighthorse, who appeals to the patriotism (and naïveté)
of the young men assembled:
empire needs you, your country needs you and your mates need
you. Now come along and find out how to get into the greatest
game of them all.
idealistic Archy has already decided to join up, telling Jack that
he wonít be returning home with him. He lies about his age, but
a rival blows his cover.
next day, one of the runners to lose to Archy, Frank Dunne (Mel
Gibson), suggests he try again in Perth. They hop a train, but realize
the next morning that their boxcar has been left behind. Not willing
to wait two weeks for the next train, Archy begins walking the 50
miles to the next town and Frank follows him through the desert.
Under a dazzling starlit sky, they discuss the war:
What are you going to join, the infantry?
Iím not joining anything.
But you gotta be in it.
Donít have to if you donít want to.
You gotta be!
No I donít. Free country, havenít you heard?
You of all people should be going Ö because youíre an athlete
Ö so why shouldnít you?
Because itís not our bloody war.
What do you mean not our war?
Itís an English war. Itís got nothiní to do with us!
a couple days of walking under the punishment of the unrelenting
Australian desert sun, Archy spots camel tracks. The camel driver
provides them much-needed food and water. As he talks to the boys,
he reveals that he knows nothing of the war that Archy is so anxious
to join. Of course, Archy knows next to nothing:
Driver: Where you headed?
Driver: You lookiní for work?
No, Iím off to the war.
Driver: What war?
The war against Germany.
Driver: I knew a German once. How did it start?
Donít know exactly, but it was the Germansí fault.
Driver: The Australians fightiní already?
Driver: Turkey? Whyís that?
Because Turkeyís a German ally.
Driver: Canít see what itís got to do with us.
We canít stop them there, they could end up here.
Driver: (After surveying the desolate landscape) And theyíre
welcome to it.
and Frank eventually make it to a house, where a generous family
welcomes them in. Over drinks, someone asks Archy why he is going
to Perth. He replies that he is going to join the Lighthorse to
fight the Turks. Everyone in the room wells up with pride. A beautiful
young woman looks lovingly at him. When asked if he is joining as
well, Frank sheepishly says he is pursuing business opportunities.
The reaction of his hosts is quite different, bordering on derision.
This contrast is not lost on Frank, and he decides shortly thereafter
to join the Lighthorse with his mate.
Frank is confronted by his father, whose house they are staying
at the night before they enlist:
What the hell do you wanna join up for? The English murdered
your own grandfather. Hung him with his own belt at the crossroads
five miles from Dublin.
Look Dad, I am not gonna fight for the British Empire. Iím gonna
keep my head down, learn a trick or two and come back an officer.
dad is not convinced, and even Frank doesnít seem to believe his
being born and raised in the city and having never been on a horse
before, Frank tries to bluff his way into the Lighthorse. A very
funny exchange ensues between Frank and Major Barton (Bill Hunter).
Any previous military experience, Dunne?
Yes sir. Five years in the Melbourne Horse Cadets.
Never heard of them.
Well, no sir. They never received as much recognition as they
call his bluff and demand a riding test. When he is unable to even
get the horse to move, he temporarily gives up on joining until
he runs into three of his mates in the pub and decides to enlist
in the infantry with them.
scene shifts to Egypt where the ANZAC forces train for their mission.
In a mock attack, the young men are jovial, taking great relish
in the war games. They are still utterly delusional about the realties
that await them in actual battle. They figure that they will kill
a few Turks and resume their civilian lives. They go into town and
barter with street vendors; they avail themselves of the services
provided by a brothel. Time of your lives, eh kids?
is surprised yet delighted to be reunited with his mate Frank. Still
caught up in the excitement of their mission, they race to the pyramids.
They climb to the top of one and discover the names of soldiers
from previous conflicts carved into the walls.
convinces Barton to let Frank into the Lighthorse, arguing that
they will not be using horses but that his speed as a sprinter will
be invaluable. When Frank shows off his new uniform to his infantry
mates, they are not amused. Snowy (David Argue), his voice dripping
with contempt, says to him, "Infantry not good enough for you
upon landing on Gallipoli, Archy remains delusional about the battle
that awaits him. With shells falling all around them on the beach,
Archy has a smile on his face. Frank, rightly annoyed by this, says,
"The thing I canít stand about you is that youíre always so
delusions of grandeur that Frank might have held are quickly dashed
when two of his mates, Barney and Snowy, die in the first day of
fighting. The true nature of war Ė senseless death Ė hits him squarely
in the jaw.
still holds to his romantic illusions of the war as he writes a
letter to his family just minutes before the major thrust of the
attack is to begin:
getting ready to make an all-out assault on Johnny Turk, and
we know weíre going to give a good account of ourselves and
our country. Everyone is terribly excited. Thereís a feeling
that weíre all involved in an adventure thatís somehow larger
speaking, the plan is for British artillery to pound the Turkish
position until precisely 4:30 when the ANZAC forces would attack
from their trenches. In what may be an indicative blunder that no
one in the military would care to admit to, the respective commanders
fail to synchronize their watches. The ANZAC commander, Major Barton,
realizes that the bombardment has inexplicably ceased seven minutes
too soon. The Turks have had time to return to their trenches. Amazingly,
the English Colonel Robinson (John Morris) orders the attack to
what seems a counterintuitive tactic, the soldiers are ordered to
empty their rifles of all ammunition and charge with "bayonets
only." The first wave is cut down by heavy machine gun fire.
Most of the men donít make it but a few yards. A second wave meets
an identical fate. With a key communication line cut, Frank, who
has been chosen as a "runner," dashes to Robinsonís bunker
to inform him of the carnage:
Tell Major Barton the attack must proceed.
Sir, I donít think youíve got the picture. They are being cut
down before they can get five yards.
Our marker flags have been seen in the Turkish trenches. The
attack must continue at all costs. I repeat: the attack must
Frank returns to the front line to deliver the order. Major Barton
is in utter disbelief. When Frank suggests he go over Robinsonís
head, Barton orders him to "go like the wind" to General
Gardner (Graham Dow), who grants a reprieve:
does sound pointless to go on Ö tell Major Barton the attack
is ó just tell him that Iím reconsidering the whole situation.
with communications restored, Robinson reiterates his order:
Those men should have gone, Barton. Marker flags have been seen.
Not by me, sir. Iíve asked for confirmation from General Gardner.
Your orders are to attack and youíll do so immediately Ö you
are to push on.
Itís cold-blooded murder.
I said push on!
the men prepare for the next wave, they understand that it is nothing
better than suicide, and they leave their letters, pictures, wedding
rings and other valuables in the trenches. Archy leaves his race
medal and the stopwatch his Uncle Jack gave him. As he prepares
to die, he repeats the mantra that Jack used to motivate him before
training sessions and races:
are your legs? Springs, steel springs. What are they going to
do? Theyíre going to haul me down the track. How fast can you
run? Fast as a leopard. How fast are you gonna run? Fast as
a leopard. Then letís see you do it!
running faster than he ever has in his life, fails to reach Barton
before he blows the whistle sending the third wave to their certain
Gallipoli, Peter Weir has given us a compelling anti-war
film. Instead of focusing mainly on the battle, he takes ample time
to develop the characters and their friendship. He depicts the way
the state glorifies war and hides its true nature from the young
men who will wage it. By taking the time to develop the story, he
makes the final scenes even more powerful.
fudges a few of the facts: the Colonel who ordered thousands to
their deaths was in fact an Aussie, not an Englishman. And despite
an implication to the contrary, thousands of Brits died in the attack
along with the ANZAC forces. Aside from the fact that it is not
a documentary, and Weir has no duty to be completely faithful to
all the details of history, he made these decisions in order to
highlight the Australian resentment of British Imperialism.
vividly demonstrates the horrors of war and the politicians and
generals who prosecute it. It exhibits their willingness, even fervor,
to sacrifice thousands of men in ill-conceived, poorly planned and
dubiously executed maneuvers. Any man who would order his boys,
armed with nothing but bayonets, to charge a trench fortified by
heavy machine gun fire is, as Major Barton avers, a cold-blooded
you rent this sparkling film, insist on the letterbox version. In
the letterbox format, a film is presented in its Original Aspect
Ratio (OAR). Most videos have been altered to fit the square box
that is a standard television screen. In order for a wide screen
film to be converted for TV screens, the film must be cropped, or
a technique such as "pan and scan" must be employed. This
is done for the masses, who donít like to see those "black
bars" on their screen, which they perceive as the movie being
smaller than it should. Of course, the opposite is the case: the
film is not presented as the director, the artist, intended. This
would be tantamount to the Art Institute of Chicago displaying their
magnificent Claude Monet collection with all the paintings covered
by black sheets on the left and right. Gallipoliís OAR is
a gorgeous panoramic 2.35:1. To see it in pan and scan is to see
only half of Weirís anti-war magnum opus.
Great Anti-War Films:
Gee (send him mail) is
a freelance writer residing in Santa Fe, New Mexico. He also authors
a monthly column "On Liberty" for The Valley News.
© 2001 LewRockwell.com
Truth Needs Your Support
make a donation to help us tell it,
no matter what nefarious plans Leviathan has.