magazine has again demonstrated its irrelevance in the Internet
age with a fatuous
feature called “25 People to Blame for the Financial Crisis.”
here is two-fold: One, the editors’ choices of who’s to
blame, and two, the reader poll ranking those choices.
start with who’s on the little list – or more to the point,
who’s not. Time did an OK job of unearthing lesser-known
names who definitely bear some culpability in the disaster –
such as AIG’s Joe Cassano, who did much to unleash the nightmare
of credit-default swaps.
But how can
anyone take this list seriously when it doesn’t include Ben
Bernanke? Yes, Greenspan (who did make the list) laid the foundation,
but Bernanke built on it with abandon. Perhaps it’s because
the intelligentsia regards him a genuine scholar on monetary matters
– you know, historian of the Great Depression and all that.
A far more respectable background than Greenspan, who hung out with
Randians and extolled the virtues of the gold standard.
Tim Geithner, the guy whose fingerprints were on every boneheaded
decision of 2008, from Bear Stearns to Lehman and beyond?
Robert Rubin? What, is there some numerical limit of Goldman Sachs
guys the editors arbitrarily applied to the list? Hank Paulson’s
on there, so Rubin can’t be? Seems like Time lays a
lot Rubin’s faux-deregulatory handiwork on the shoulders of
Bill Clinton, which I daresay might be a bit unfair. Clinton revealed
his navet on such matters when he remarked
early in his first term, “You mean to tell me that the success
of the economic program and my re-election hinges on the Federal
Reserve and a bunch of f*$(#@g bond traders?”
Oh, and then
there’s Time’s inclusion of “The American
Consumer.” Oh, that was clever, alright. I bet the editors
were congratulating themselves over the brilliance of that one –
“Gee, this is almost as good as choosing ‘You’ as
Person of the Year a while back!” But this too is too harsh
– consumers were merely taking their cues from the politicians
and central bankers driving the ship.
than Time’s 25 choices are the rankings furnished by
its readers. I guess letting the readers vote is Time’s
idea of Web 2.0. But the sheer folly of this is revealed when the
number-one choice as ranked by the people who drove by the website,
the premier villain of the financial calamity that’s befallen
us is… drum roll, please… Phil Gramm.
Yes, his name was the first on the faux-deregulation legislation
that repealed Glass-Steagall in 1999, and he’s worthy of inclusion
on the list. But I suspect the reason he ranks so high is one that
Time doesn’t even mention in its write-up: His Kudlowesque
comment last year, while on UBS’s payroll and consulting the
McCain campaign, that the recession is a mere figment of the collective
imagination. Must’ve stuck in the craw of a lot of political
And if we’re
going to beat up on former members of Congress, shouldn’t we
beat up on a couple of others who are still around, like Barney
Frank or Chris Dodd?
Time’s payroll and page count shrinks as the economy
and the Internet take their toll. Let us celebrate.
Gonigam [send him mail]
joined Agora Financial in 2007 after a 20-year career as an Emmy
award-winning writer, producer, and manager in local TV newsrooms