between the current US occupation of Iraq and events depicted in
the movie The Battle of Algiers have been widely discussed. The
1965 classic, a dramatization of anticolonial struggle, was even
shown at the Pentagon back in 2003,
apparently as an instructional film.
But, as a few
commentators have noted, there is another movie from the past which,
if held up to an ideological mirror, provides insights on the Iraq
Dawn, released – appropriately enough – in 1984,
was rotten cinema; however,
as an example of Cold War paranoia it was a masterpiece. Depicting
a near-future Soviet invasion of the United States, the film followed
the struggle of a group of young Coloradans against the forces of
At the time
of its release, denunciations of Red Dawn focused on the
absurdity of the movie’s premise – a successful land invasion
by Soviet forces – and its potential to feed anticommunist
hysteria. But I don’t remember anyone criticizing its portrayal
of ordinary Americans’ determination to resist an invasion, should
my hands a copy of Red Dawn’s original shooting script (screenplay
by Kevin Reynolds), I’ll use it to illustrate how, beneath the Hollywood
hokum, the film made two important points: (1) whatever the odds,
people will inevitably fight back against an invading army and (2)
military occupation triggers a downward spiral of brutality on both
First, two short excerpts:
with invading troops at an abandoned drive-in theater]
barely have time to react. A murderous BARRAGE cuts into them.
Some dive for weapons.
an RPG ROUND into a truck. It blows up.
A few bleeding
soldiers take cover behind the movie screen, wild with fright.
Robert shoots them.
Is that all of them?
don’t take prisoners?
Jed: We don’t
has landed around him. Tremendous NOISE OF HEAT SHELLS ripping
into the earth with their shaped charges. A shrieking WAIL as
an anti-tank missile glances off the T2′s turret without detonating.
at Robert – Daryl – Tony; they all look at him. He leaps
to his feet, running. They are right behind him. Shells streak
in, the Russian GUN FIRES. They bolt, gasping air in headlong
who two decades ago might have cheered on the boys of Red Dawn
are likely to see the Iraqi resistance very differently, viewing
it as a movement dominated by non-Iraqi jihadists bent on killing
civilians. That is certainly the impression one gets from watching
news on the small screen.
that most suicide bombers are foreigners appears to be true. But
the wider resistance – 30,000 or so strong – is overwhelmingly
Iraqi. A November 17 Washington Post article cited
estimates by analyst Anthony Cordesman and others that foreigners
make up between 4 and 10 percent of all guerrillas currently in
Iraq. According to Cordesman, "Both Iraqis and coalition people
often exaggerate the role of foreign infiltrators and downplay the
role of Iraqi resentment in the insurgency."
by the homegrown Iraqi resistance against Americans and their supporters
must be condemned (just as we condemn the violence committed by
the occupying army), but it also must be understood as the absolutely
predictable reaction of a people under the thumb of a foreign superpower.
It doesn’t matter if the foreigner’s flag is red or if it’s red,
white, and blue.
The young rebels
in Red Dawn also did not shrink from cruel behavior: executing
prisoners, scalping Mexican members of the Soviet-led "coalition,"
and engaging in torture. To its credit, the script takes a dim view
of such behavior; the young heroes who committed the acts appeared
not to enjoy them, but to regard them as a grim necessity under
of the camp – pre-dawn.
sits crosslegged and stoic in the dirt, his elbows tied behind
him. He’s nineteen.
Matt question him – nervously. Half-dressed kids madly grab belongings
in the background…
the compass device up to the Commando’s face.
Sandy slaps the prisoner. Robert holds up a cigarette.
a butt on him!
scared, so she does. The Commando yells, flails in pain.
Suck at you! Goddam for your mother!
over and grabs him by his sweaty shirt.
did you find us?
(is scared, but he has been trained): You fock, Yankee!
Jed: If you
wanna live, talk.
locks his face.
Gorsky, Stepan Yevgeny … Lieutenant –
him in the stomach as hard as he can.
cares who you are, asshole.
him again … and again … and again …
occupation can be successfully opposed by nonviolent means, but
that depends on the citizens of the invading nation. (Even Gandhi
admitted that his followers’ nonviolent independence movement may
not have succeeded against another colonial power less accommodating
than postwar Britain). The violent Iraqi resistance to US occupation
continues because we in this country have so far been thwarted in
our attempts to force an end to the war or the occupation through
If, in America,
the tide really is beginning to turn in favor of an end to the occupation,
many lives will be saved …but too late for thousands of Americans
and tens of thousands of Iraqis. If leading Democratic lawmakers
continue to resist the will of a solid majority of citizens and
allow the occupation to continue, it will be too late for thousands
Two more scenes.
This time, I have changed the names of the young American fighters
to names that could be those of young Iraqis. And I have given American
names and designations to the Russians (Try doing the same with
the scenes above as well):
different up close.
get used to it after a while.
can see that.
must be something to kill a man from ten miles away. To sit warm
in your plane and see that little flash in the distance. No body,
no blood, no screams.
Put a medal on the boy… shot dead and he still got us down.
drag two torn rag dolls into a pile – Ghalib, Bashir. Their weapons
are stacked beside them.
with a movie camera films the spectacle from various angles, then
turns the camera on Strickland.
POV – CAMERA
is reframed to avoid the dead pilot in background.
official: I would estimate preliminary enemy body count to 12
K.I.A., wouldn’t you, Sergeant?
I see two.
official: But they carry off their dead.
boot, Strickland lifts Ghalib’s head for a closeup. There is a
distant, dull explosion.
these exchanges make sense when relocated from Colorado to Iraq,
it’s because as a cycle of violence progresses, the actions of one
side become harder and harder to distinguish from those of the other.
The original motivations of the invader and the natural desire of
the invaded to defend their home territory both get lost in the
the Pentagon assigned the code name "Red Dawn" to the
operation that captured Saddam Hussein in December, 2003. Clearly,
no one involved in selecting that name was familiar with the movie
– or maybe they had a keen sense of humor. And the irony of the
choice, at a time when a heavily armed United States was playing
the role of an invader battling a ragtag army of locals, was overlooked
by all but a few in the press.
But more than
20 years after it first landed in theaters, the much-maligned Red
Dawn may finally have found a useful role in society, by prompting
us to put ourselves in the shoes of Iraqis – or Palestinians,
or any other people – who are living under occupation.
Cox [send him mail] is a plant
breeder and writer in Salina, Kansas.