Why I Can't Afford to Shop at Wal-Mart, But I Do Anyway

Email Print

habits die hard. Sometimes good old habits become bad old habits.
We still can’t break them easily.

I don’t go shopping very often. I use amazingly few items. Two eggs,
half a banana, and a shot of molasses: breakfast drink. Maybe a
piece of toast. Some meat and vegetables for lunch. Maybe the same
for dinner. Not much to it. Clothes: a pair of cheap pants (Sam’s
Club), a shirt (same for a week), and a daily change of underwear.
I walk 200 yards to my office. I’m alone. Who cares what I wear?
Not my two dogs, one of whom swims in the pond, then lies in the
mud, and then wipes his paw on my pants to get his ears scratched.
(He has me well trained.)

So, shopping is not my bag. But when I shop, I usually shop at Wal-Mart.
I shouldn’t.

No, not because Wal-Mart dropped its “We Buy American” banner three
years ago. Not because it’s a rapacious company that is putting
mom-and-pop businesses (e.g., K-Mart) out of business. It’s because
I can’t afford to shop there.

Aren’t prices low, every day? Yes. Isn’t there a wide range of goods?
Enormous. Then what’s wrong with shopping at Wal-Mart?

It’s too big.

First, there is the parking lot. Have you ever been in a near-empty
parking lot at Wal-Mart? I never have. So, I have to walk a long
way to get inside. It eats up my time. My time is valuable.

Once inside, I’m in a small town. Where is everything? I don’t know.
I don’t shop there that often. But it probably won’t be close to
the door that was close to the area of the parking lot where I found
a space.

Sometimes, I know where to go. Milk is way, way in the back. I drink
a special kind. A local company sells skim milk that doesn’t have
the skim milk taste we all hate. It’s called “extra.” It costs an
extra 25 cents per gallon, I think. But they also sell it at our
local market, too — when they haven’t run out, which happens too
often. They never run out at Wal-Mart.

Fruits and vegetables? They sell those locally. Bread? This I can
get only at Wal-Mart: Oroweat 12-grain. That’s what gets me into
the place once every month or so. I usually buy every loaf, bring
them home, and freeze them.

People with substantial incomes really can’t afford to shop there.
Going to Wal-Mart takes too much time. Time is valuable. Standing
in line takes time. You stand in line at Wal-Mart, unless you know
the “get out fast” secret. This works especially well in the Super
Center behemoths. If I walk into a local market, I can get in and
out fast. I pay a few percentage points more, but my time is worth
something to me — more than the extra cost of the food. Yet
I still shop at Wal-Mart.

For tires, however, I never shop at Wal-Mart. It takes too much
time to get the work done. The Good Old Boys’ Tire Store and Assorted
Grease-Covered Spare Parts Company in my town (population: 1600)
is just about as cheap, a lot faster, and they sometimes fix stuff
for free.


Most people in the United States with a lot of money earned it themselves
— about 80% of them. They started small businesses that got
big. That’s the message of The
Millionaire Next Door
, and it’s true.

I was a starving graduate student for years. Well, not starving,
but I had to hustle. I wrote articles for The Freeman. I
worked part time as a teaching assistant. Things were tight. So,
like most people who finally make a lot of money, I developed habits
of thrift that I can’t break.

The poor man doesn’t place high value on his time. He prefers to
stand in line rather than pay extra money. Scarce resources are
allocated either by time or money. People who get rich developed
the habit of trading off time against money. Then, when their income
changes, their habits don’t. These habits don’t depart when the
money starts rolling in. “A penny saved is a penny earned,” said
Ben Franklin. He did not face the graduated income tax. “A penny
saved is 1.3 cents earned, depending on your marginal tax bracket.”
So, I don’t spend extra money.

In a way, I guess shopping at Wal-Mart can be considered economical
for a rich man, if this is a part of his life style that carries
over into his business. He refuses to write larger checks even though
he can afford to.

For a man with a lot of money, it is a mistake to pay a low price
whenever there is either training involved in using the item, or
the dreaded phrase, “some assembly required.”

There is another risk: the thing won’t work out of the box. Sam
Walton understood this, as a rich man who never abandoned his poor
boy’s roots. That’s why he adopted a 100% exchange plan. His cost-cutting
marketing strategy depends on the absence of on-site repair facilities.
So, when you buy anything at Wal-Mart that doesn’t work, take it
back and get a new replacement. This happens so rarely that it pays
for the policy of not having on-site repair facilities.

Wal-Mart makes at least one exception to its “no service” rule for
commodities (as distinguished from its pharmacy): a Wal-Mart Super
Center’s watch department, which will change the battery in your
watch, cheap. If this service were not available, some of us would
not buy watches from Wal-Mart.


I don’t understand the conservatives’ hostility to Wal-Mart. The
company offers the option of paying low prices to people who favor
the trade-off between time for money. That’s millions of people.
Wal-Mart makes their lives better. In those areas of shopping in
which we favor saving time over saving money, we can go to our local
mom-and-pop market, or its economic equivalent in our day, the 24-hour
convenience store.

And yet, and yet . . . you don’t see many new Cadillacs or old Rolls-Royces
in front of convenience stores. You see used cars owned by folks
who probably should pay more attention to higher prices than they
pay to fast shopping time. Old habits die hard, good and bad. As
powerful as the logic of rational economic choice is in economic
theory, any theory of self-interested decision-making that ignores
the effects of habit is not much of a theory. It is long on equations
and short on common sense.

16, 2002

North is the author of Mises
on Money
. Visit http://www.freebooks.com.
For a free subscription to Gary North’s twice-weekly economics newsletter,

North Archives

Email Print